Wednesday, November 14, 2007

Monti’s Restaurant in Tempe will have neighboring towers

[Source: Garin Groff, Tribune] -- Michael Monti has made peace with historic preservationists who blasted his initial plan to build a high-rise tower above the Valley’s oldest building. Tempe’s Historic Preservation Commission signed off on his plans Thursday to build two towers next to Monti’s La Casa Vieja, just weeks after rejecting an earlier proposal. Monti’s first plan included a pair of towers, one of which would have stood on piers that surrounded the adobe structure built in 1871. Critics said the plan shrouded the building and could get it kicked off state and national historic registries.

The new plan leaves the oldest part of the building as it stands today, and won compliments from those who opposed the original plan. The building is perhaps the Valley’s most significant historic structure. It was built by Tempe founder Charles Trumbull Hayden, whose son Carl was born in the house. Carl Hayden served in Congress for 57 years and has been called Arizona’s most important person. Monti plans to tear down newer additions to the restaurant and keep the oldest 11,000 square feet of the structure. He intends to sell the property to developer 3W Cos. but continue to operate the restaurant that his father bought in the 1950s. The new buildings will include shops, condos and a hotel. The hotel’s name will include the name Hayden. [Image source: DFD CornoyerHedrick, the same architectural firm that proposed the design concept for condos in and atop the Sun Mercantile Building in downtown Phoenix.]

New $1.3M Tempe home splits neighbors

[Source: Tony Natale, Tribune] -- A new, $1.3 million house in an old Tempe neighborhood near downtown where most homes are valued between $250,000 and $350,000 is both a blessing and a curse to local residents. However, for its builder, Jimmy Evans (pictured), 40, the house is a gamble that Evans hopes will result in both a bottom-line profit and the start of a building trend he can profitably repeat in other older Tempe communities. After Evans sought and won approval from Tempe to build the comparatively expensive home, residents of the area — with Evans’ encouragement — sought and won approval from the city and the Historic Preservation Commission to be declared an official historic district. In historic districts, builders are restricted from erecting homes, condos, apartments or other dwellings that do not meet historical or cultural requirements. For example, they can now build only one-story houses that architecturally blend with the surrounding ones.

Today, Evans’ new one-story house stands at 610 W. Third St. and is among 20 others along a cul-de-sac at Third and Roosevelt streets. It is also the newest home in the newly created Roosevelt Addition Historic District and the only one bearing a for sale sign. “I pushed the movement toward establishing an historic district because, like the people who live in the neighborhood, I, too, didn’t want developers to come in and build condos or high-rises,” said Evans, owner of J Evans Construction, who lives with his wife and two children in Ahwatukee Foothills. Not everybody in the neighborhood agrees. “It’s not the kind of home I think should have been built here,” said Mike Wood, who lives at 624 W. Third St. “This is an old neighborhood with old homes, and I think the new home looks like a giant 'McMansion’ that just plopped down out of the sky.” Wood admitted that until the home was constructed, neighbors were delaying any action toward seeking historic identification. He agreed that establishing a historic district was beneficial toward restricting developers from building high-rises.

[Note: To read the full article, click here. Photo source: Bettina Hansen, Tribune.]

Dec. 3 deadline for proposals to move historic/vintage Evans Churchill properties

The City of Phoenix, Arizona seeks proposals from persons or entities with the financial and technical capability to acquire, relocate, and renovate four residential buildings within an area bounded by 4th, 6th, Pierce, and Garfield Streets. Proposals for structure demolition and salvage will not be considered. Destination sites for the relocated structures must be in the City of Phoenix.

Information packets may be obtained beginning Monday October 8, 2007. An electronic version of the packet is available on the City of Phoenix Downtown Development Office website. Or, click here for materials.

The deadline for proposals is Monday December 3, 2007 at Noon. For further information, contact Donna Stevens, Program Manager, at 602-495-0376.

Tuesday, November 13, 2007

Teachers encouraged to design social studies lesson plans using historic places

The Arizona Preservation Foundation is proud to announce the 1st Annual Statewide Contest for teachers to create lesson plans based on Arizona national, state, and local historic places that adheres to Arizona State Social Studies Standards. Contest rules:
  1. Use Teaching with Historic Places (TwHP) format.
  2. Submit three copies with cover sheet (name, grade(s) taught, school name, address, and e-mail) with no identification on lesson.
  3. Send to: Arizona Preservation Foundation, P.O. Box 13492, Phoenix, AZ 85002, ATTN: Centennial Lesson Plan Contest.
  4. Postmark no later than April 1, 2008.
  5. For problems, questions, etc., contact Donna Reiner, PhD, contest chair.
  6. 1st place winner will receive $250, 2nd place $200, 3rd place $150.
  7. Winners announced at the 6th Annual Arizona Statewide Historic Preservation Conference, June 11-13, 2008 in Rio Rico, AZ.

Governor seeks volunteers to serve on state boards and commissions

Governor Janet Napolitano invites you to apply to serve on one of the State of Arizona's Boards and Commissions. Openings on two history-related bodies exist:

As of 9/1/2007, four vacancies on the Archaeology Advisory Commission. Each member shall have a demonstrated interest or expertise in one or more of the fields of prehistory archaeology, historic archaeology, anthropology, ethnology, tourism, public education, planning, or economic development.

As of 7/21/2006, one vacancy on the Parkways and Historic and Scenic Roads Advisory Committee.

Take a peek at past Arizona Highways Television segments

Journalist Robin Sewell is your tour guide as the host of the Arizona Highways Television series. Click here for links to videos of past segments, many of them featuring Arizona historic and archaeological sites. If you have a story idea, contact ATH by mail (7000 N. 16th St., #120, Phoenix, AZ 85020) or phone (602-952-7399).

Propose a session for the 2008 National Preservation Conference

The National Trust for Historic Preservation invites you to submit a proposal for an education session for the National Preservation Conference in Tulsa, Oklahoma, October 21 – 25, 2008. We seek proposals that present critical issues that challenge communities across the country and cutting-edge historic preservation strategies and models that address these. We invite a broad range of proposals that include cultural, subject matter, and geographic diversity.

The National Trust uses an on-line session proposal submission system, which will make your submission experience easy, fun, and efficient. Click the links in the navigation bar above to access the system. To print the instructions on developing, submitting, and managing Education Sessions or Field Sessions, click below:
Important dates to remember for the submission process are:
  • Friday, January 11 ~ Proposal submission deadline
  • February ~ National Trust reviews, refines and/or combines session proposals
  • Thursday, March 1 ~ Affinity event application deadline
  • Week of March 10 ~ National Trust notifies applicants of acceptance or rejection of proposal
  • March 10-18 ~ National Trust revises session description for inclusion in Preliminary Program
  • Monday, April 7 ~ Session managers receive budget and speaker paperwork
  • Friday, April 25 ~ Session budget and final speaker information due
  • Monday, June 2 ~ National Trust mails Preliminary Program to session manager, moderator, and speakers with taping authorization and audio-visual equipment request forms
  • Wednesday, July 30 ~ Recording authorization forms due
  • October 21-25 ~ National Preservation Conference 2008
  • Monday, December 1 ~ Expense reimbursement requests due

Questions? Please contact conference@nthp.org. Begin the online submission process for Education Sessions and Poster Sessions.

Monday, November 12, 2007

Henry Wickenburg to stay put

[Source: Janet DelTufo, Wickenburg Sun] -- Town Founding Father Henry Wickenburg will not be moved from his current gravesite location and will remain on a hill off of Howard Court with other former town dignitaries. A decision regarding the location of Wickenburg’s grave, which has been a source of discussion for several months, was finally made Monday night (Nov. 5). The original plan to move his tomb, along with the tomb of at least four other former Wickenburg residents, was rescinded from an earlier council decision. “I visited the gravesite, and I had second thoughts,” said Mayor Ron Badowski. “The gravesites are in good shape, and this is not a matter of state dollars, but leaving him where he should be. I thought at first we should move the tombs, and I now apologize for leaning that way. I would like to leave Henry where he is right now.”

No one in the audience or any other council member voiced an opposing view. Everyone seemed to agree with the mayor’s sentiments. Resident Paul Woley spoke first to the council, shedding new light on the situation. He informed the audience that Henry Cowell, who is in a larger tomb with his wife Lydia next to Wickenburg, was the town’s first-ever mayor. “Wickenburg is sort of known as an Old West town, and who we were and what we did in the past defines us,” Woley said. “It is important not to ignore our history, and moving Henry Wickenburg is ignoring history. You have to realize that any change we make changes what we were in the past. Leaving Henry where he is gives us an opportunity to tell a story, and I encourage you to think about keeping that history alive and keeping the grave where it is now.”

Businessman Bill Green also spoke on behalf of not moving the tombs and to allow the former residents to rest in peace. “Henry has been there for 100 years or more, and the gravesites are in very nice shape,” Green said. “I would, however, be opposed to spending any tax money to improve the walkway. I even think a wheelchair can be pushed up the hill (with the existing walkway).”

Green also said there should be no issue with encroachment in order to get to the gravesite because individuals have been using the walkway for 100 years. However, Cindy Thrasher of the Wickenburg Historical Preservation Society said that the property owner who is being encroached upon wrote a letter to the town several years ago making note of the issue. “I think the town should purchase the property in question,” Thrasher said. “We are going to have problems whether we move the tombs or leave them where they are, and we will have to eventually address these problems.”

Thrasher suggested installing a fence around the area and adding directional signage to the gravesite. “If we leave the tombs where they are, improvements need to be made,” Thrasher said. “Either site is appropriate, but if we leave the graves where they are, we will need to make some decisions as to how we are going to improve the area.” Thrasher will again need to go in front of the council to address the situation, since there was no resolution during the meeting as to how the improvements would be addressed. [Photo source: Frank Barrios and Reba Grandrud]

Sunday, November 11, 2007

Irreplaceable parts of Tucson destroyed

[Source: Arizona Daily Star, Opinion] -- For the second time this year, incompetence has resulted in the destruction of a piece of Tucson that cannot be replaced. This time it was a historic building. Last February, it was a stand of giant saguaros. In both cases, we've been told, the destruction was unintentional, a mistake, a glitch, a miscommunication. Outrageous nonetheless. Ignorance and insensitivity, the disengaged mind, also play a hand. At what point do we say the consequences are inexcusable? The most recent "mistake" resulted in the destruction of a historic building in Udall Park. The building was an outpost of the U.S. Magnetic Observatory, a relic of science as it was practiced in the 1920s.

A demolition crew hired by the city went to the park sometime during the last month. It was supposed to take down 10 buildings that were part of the observatory complex. Instead, the crew took down 11 buildings. Marty McCune, the city's historic preservation officer, said in a Star story on Tuesday: "It's always a loss when you lose historic resources. It was simply a miscommunication, a human mistake." In the future, maybe such errors can be avoided by wrapping some police crime scene tape around the building and planting a sign out front that says, "Do not destroy." Tucson has a reputation as a community that values its heritage and its history. We need to do more to live up to that reputation. Last February, a similar "human error" resulted in the destruction of a stand of giant saguaros for a new housing development near West Speedway and North Silverbell Road. [Note: To read the full article, click here.]

Plans back on track to restore Mesa's historic Alston house

[Source: Lindsay Butler, East Valley Tribune] -- Plans to restore the home of Mesa’s first black doctor have reawakened after being dormant for months. The Alston House, at the corner of Fifth Street and Pima near Washington Park, was built in the 1920s and was home to Dr. Lucius Alston who used it to treat patients from the community. The house has particular significance to the black and Hispanic communities in Mesa, and it will house offices for the Mesa Martin Luther King Jr. Celebration Committee and the Mesa Association of Hispanic Citizens. “It’s going to help us out tremendously to have a place to meet, something stable we can call our own,” said Everette Woods, MLK committee vice president. “And it will be a place for the community to look out and say, ‘This is ours.’ ” Mesa’s Historic Preservation Office has been working on restoring the house for years, but the progress slowed this summer when preservation officer Stephanie Bruning took a job out of state.

[Note: To read the full article, click here. Photo source: Lisa Olson, East Valley Tribune.]

Temple of doom

[Source: Sarah Fenske, Phoenix New Times] -- In a city where everybody is nice, where conference tables in fancy law firms take the place of the proverbial smoke-filled room, Michael Levine is something else. He is not particularly nice. Nor is he a law firm kind of guy, or even a conference table kind of guy. ("Michael doesn't do well in meetings," one of his friends tells me.) He's abrasive and outspoken, and if you don't like it, he just might just lob an F-bomb at you in his New Yawk accent. So I practically fell off my chair last week when Levine told me that he'd hired a lawyer for his latest crusade. And not just any lawyer. The buzz around town is he's got somebody at Lewis and Roca, the bluest of blue-chip firms. In a case like the one I'm about to describe, you don't hire Lewis and Roca to sue. You hire them to finesse the inside game. Even Levine is a little sheepish about it. "Hey, I usually go in with my guns blazing and let the dust settle later," he tells me. "But now I have an attorney."

So here's the story: Levine is fighting to save an old Jewish temple in downtown Phoenix. Here's the catch: Though he's a developer and preservationist with plenty of holdings downtown, Levine doesn't actually own the building in question. The building's owner, the nonprofit Black Theatre Troupe, is in escrow with someone else — developers likely interested in building a high-rise on the site, at Portland Street just east of Third Street. And until the deal closes in three months, the theater troupe won't even tell Levine its buyer's name. No wonder Michael Levine has resorted to the trappings of respectability. This fight is not going to be easy.

[Note: To read the full article, click here. Photo source: Tony Blei, New Times.]

A toast to saving a bit of Phoenix's history

[Source: Scott Craven, Arizona Republic] -- Phoenix isn't known for cherishing history. Older homes, offices and other buildings routinely have been torn down over the decades to make way for the new and improved, if not as distinctive. Which makes the survival of 816 N. Third St. all the more remarkable. The modest home hardly seems the survivor type, what with its red bricks flecked with paint layered on over the years, and its location just enough off the beaten path to make it difficult to notice. Matt Pool never looked twice at the single-story structure, though he would drive past it every day on his way to work. But what Pool did see one day two years ago was the "For Lease" sign suddenly posted in the front yard.

Pool, looking for a space in which to open a neighborhood tavern, had unknowingly stumbled upon the Farish House, built in 1900 and one of the handful of homes that somehow had escaped the city's penchant for destroying the old to make room for the new. Charmed by the home's historical quaintness, Pool - owner of the popular downtown restaurant Matt's Big Breakfast and a former bartender - soon would sign a lease. The result was Roosevelt Tavern, making the home perhaps more popular now than it had been in its previous 107 years. Few of those sipping an ice-cold beer fresh from the Roosevelt's super-cooled taps realize they are sitting in one of the few downtown homes that have survived for more than a century; intact, and in the same location.

[Note: To read the full article, click here. Photo source: Roosevelt Row.]

Tempe pub demolished to make way for hotel

[Source: Jeff Mitchell, ASU Web Devil] -- A towering yellow excavator stood over concrete rubble, steel cables and topsoil Thursday where the Bandersnatch Brew Pub once stood. "It's a sad day," said Vic Linoff, owner of Those Were The Days! Bookstore at 516 S. Mill Ave. for decades. "Bandersnatch was an icon for downtown." The pub is making room for an 11-story Residence Inn by Marriott, said Darcy Gray, senior project manager for Layton Construction, the firm overseeing the demolition. Bandersnatch, which sat at Forest Avenue and Fifth Street, opened in the 1970s and was a unique pub, Linoff said. It had an outdoor volleyball court, microbrew tanks and grills where customers could make their own burgers, he said. Interior design senior Meredith Nunn said older buildings being demolished for new development was a recent pattern in Tempe.

[Note: To read the full article, click here. Photo source: Chris Atwood, State Press.]

Thursday, November 08, 2007

NAU starts Heritage Management Journal

Heritage Management is a global, peer-reviewed journal that provides a venue for using scholarly, professional, and indigenous knowledge to address broader societal concerns about managing cultural heritage. It will address issues of resource management, cultural preservation and revitalization, education, legal/legislative developments, public archaeology, and ethics. The journal presents an engaging forum for those who work with governmental and tribal agencies, museums, private CRM firms, indigenous communities, and colleges and universities. It will facilitate a multivocal arena for disseminating and critically discussing cultural heritage management issues collaboratively among professionals and stakeholders.

Heritage Management will include peer-reviewed research on policy, legislation, ethics, and methods in heritage management and will showcase exemplary projects and models of public interpretation and interaction. A peer-reviewed Forum section presents position statements and responses on key current issues. The journal also includes reviews of books, web pages, exhibits, and resources in various media.

Submission Guidelines: Heritage Management welcomes submission of original manuscripts of no more than 30 double spaced pages that focus on management of the world’s heritage resources. All manuscripts are subject to anonymous peer review by knowledgeable scholars and professional practitioners and, if accepted, may be subject to revision. Materials submitted to HMJ should not be under consideration by other publishers, nor should they be previously published in any form. Submissions should include an original manuscript sent via email in MS Word or RTF format. Manuscripts should be submitted with low resolution illustrations that can be easily be transmitted via email. They should include a title page that has the article title, names, and full contact information of all authors; and an abstract of no more than 200 words.

Manuscript style generally should conform to Society for American Archaeology Style Guide. Non-conforming manuscripts will be returned to the author(s) for revision. Additional details concerning preparation of final manuscripts accepted for publication can be located at Left Coast Press or from the editors. For other questions and correspondence, contact one of the co-editors, Kelley Hays-Gilpin and George Gumerman IV at Northern Arizona University

The journal will be published semi-annually in March and September, 288 pages per volume, starting in March 2008. One year subscription prices: Individuals: $40; Heritage Orgs: $89 (paper), $140 (paper and electronic); Institutions: $149 (paper), $249 (paper and electronic).

Old Arizona resides within these hotels

[Source: Kelli M. Donley, Arizona Republic] -- Interested in seeing a new area of Arizona, but don't know where to stay? Before you log on to a mass-market travel Web site or jump into the car without a reservation, consider making your visit entertaining and educational by staying at a historic hotel. Rolling your eyes at the thought of a dusty saloon and trite cowboy decor? Hold your horses: Historic doesn't mean clichéd or that your room will smell as though Wyatt Earp just checked out. With spa services, museums and even reported ghosts (and, to be fair, the occasional dusty saloon), historic hotels from the Mexican border to Route 66 provide a different and less standardized experience.

To be considered a historic hotel by the National Trust for Historic Preservation, hotels must be in a building that is at least 50 years old, recognized locally for their historical significance, or listed on or eligible for the National Register of Historic Places.

Hotel Gadsden. The Gadsden is easy to find in downtown Douglas: A large sign stands tall atop the historic building in this border town. The quiet street draws little traffic and seems like a set from a 1950s television show. The lobby is impressive. Your eye is drawn past marble columns and up the white Italian marble staircase to a series of stained-glass windows on the second floor. Light pours through the desert scenes depicted in the Tiffany glass, casting a rainbow of colors on the lobby floor.

Pancho Villa once rode a horse up those very stairs, which were among the few things to survive a sweeping fire that nearly destroyed the Gadsden in 1929. The hotel opened in 1907 and is named after the Gadsden Purchase of land that is now part of Arizona and New Mexico. Famous guests have included movie stars - much of the 1994 movie Terminal Velocity featuring Charlie Sheen was filmed at the hotel - and dignitaries, including Eleanor Roosevelt. The hotel has 130 rooms, a coffee shop, dining rooms and a beauty salon, among other amenities. In addition to heading across the border for a day trip to Mexico, Gadsden guests often visit the Cochise Stronghold, an Apache hideout in the Dragoon Mountains; Kartchner Caverns; and the ghost towns of Gleeson and Paradise.

Some people come here to visit doctors and dentists in nearby Agua Prieta, Sonora, says hotel manager Robin Brekhus. "Others come to escape the heat. It's a great place to stay for a weekend to visit the Wonderland of Rocks (in Chiricahua National Monument) and go hiking or have a picnic, or to visit nearby places like Rodeo, N.M., or Bisbee or Tombstone." The hotel was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1976, in part because of its manual telephone switchboard, installed in 1929. The switchboard was the first in the state and can be seen behind the front desk.

Where: 1046 G Ave. Douglas is about 230 miles southeast of central Phoenix. Take Interstate 10 east through Tucson to Exit 303 at Benson. Go south on Arizona 80 past Tombstone and Bisbee to Douglas, where the state route turns into G Avenue. Rates: $60-$150 per night. Details: 520-364-4481 or www.hotelgadsden.com.

Copper Queen Hotel. Bisbee is a quaint town often overlooked by Phoenicians seeking cooler climates. Although plenty of residents of this former mining town are happy that their rolling hills haven't turned into a regular weekend retreat like Payson or Pinetop-Lakeside, cooler weather, antiques and curio shops also are found here. And a great hotel. "I moved here for the small-town life I'd been looking for in Tucson," says Adam Lamb, operating manager at the Copper Queen, tipping back his large straw cowboy hat. "You can walk down the main street and have people look you in the eye and say hello, or invite you in for a beer. Plus, we run an average of 10 to 15 degrees cooler than Tucson and 15 to 20 degrees cooler than Phoenix."

Phelps Dodge began building the Copper Queen in 1898 and finished it four years later, providing the perfect atmosphere in which to entertain potential investors. With a few significant changes over the years, the hotel now has 52 rooms, no two alike. The five-story building has four levels of rooms, with the fifth floor housing the mechanics of the elevator, installed in the 1940s. "The hotel went on the National Register of Historic Places in 1980," Lamb says. "The hotel is Arizona's longest continuously operating hotel; her doors have never been closed in all 106 years."

Many visitors come to see the hotel's rumored ghosts; the Copper Queen was featured on the television show Ghost Hunters. The most popular "haunted" request is to stay in the Julia Lowell room. Lowell was a prostitute who reportedly took her life at the hotel after being left brokenhearted. "I do believe it is haunted," Lamb says. "I've seen a confused little girl several times." A ghost register at the front desk features vivid stories written by guests. Lamb says the staff is working to have the stories published.

It is easy to fall in love with the Copper Queen. The rooms are clean, and the hotel grounds are tidy. Breakfast is served on the patio under hanging baskets of colorful flowers, guests can take in panoramic views of the surrounding hills, and even the bowl of root-beer candies on the front desk is welcoming. Guests come to enjoy the Bisbee Pride festival in June, blues festival in September and wine festival in October. Fuel your day with a cup of Eureka, espresso and coffee at the Bisbee Coffee Co., across the street from the hotel. "There is a lot of history here in this little old mining town at the bottom of the canyon," Lamb says.

Where: 11 Howell Ave. Bisbee is about 200 miles southeast of central Phoenix. Take Interstate 10 east through Tucson to Exit 303 at Benson. Go south on Arizona 80 past Tombstone to Bisbee. Go left at the Old Bisbee exit, then left on Naco Road, right on Brewery Avenue and immediately left on Howell Avenue. Rates: $122-$200 per night. Details: 520-432-2216 or www.copperqueen.com.

Hotel Congress. Maneuvering through the construction and one-way streets in downtown Tucson can be tricky, but the reward is worth the hassle. The Hotel Congress, built in 1919, is where John Dillinger and members of his gang hid out before they moved to a nearby apartment, where police arrested them in 1934. Today, the Congress is a hip alternative to a chain hotel. The Cup Cafe boasts a mean cup of joe and an impressive display of baked goods, and the floor is made entirely of copper pennies. The sounds of jazz pour out of Club Congress, just off the lobby. The front desk sits aptly between the two worlds: caffeine on one side and alcohol on the other. Similarly, the hotel seems to meld rich history with a contemporary vibe. "The Hotel Congress is in the heart of downtown, which includes an amazing arts and entertainment district, including the Rialto Theatre, the Fox Theatre and Tucson Children's Museum," says Todd Hanley, general manager.

Rooms are clean and vintage; they have radios and reading lamps but no televisions. The decor varies, with the most noticeable being the garish paint by artist Larry Boyce. He described his style as "Southwest Deco" when he painted the lobby and staircase in 1989. The orange, green and purple jump out from the walls, which also hold framed pieces for sale from local artists. The old-fashioned telephone booths on the lobby floor top the urban feel with an antique icing. Pets are welcome, and the hotel has Wi-Fi service. The Hotel Congress was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 2003.

Where: 311 E. Congress Ave. Tucson is about 110 miles from central Phoenix. Take Interstate 10 east to Speedway Boulevard (Exit 257), go left on Speedway, right on Fourth Avenue, then right on Congress Avenue. Rates: $69-$119 per night September through May. Rates are lower in summer. Details: 520-622-8848 or www.hotelcongress.com.