Thursday, November 08, 2007

Phoenix's "mushroom" bank and grounds spared...for now

[Source: Michael Clancy, Arizona Republic] -- One redevelopment project at a controversial Arcadia neighborhood intersection got the green light, but two others were curbed by decisions of the Phoenix City Council on Wednesday evening. The council decisions end for now a long and argumentative process for redevelopment of three corners at Camelback Road and 44th Street.

The council approved the project proposed for the southwest corner, where Grace Communities wants to erect nine buildings topping out at four stories that would house 175,000 square feet of retail and office, as well as 42 condominiums and a 125-room hotel. The project will wrap around the Londen Center, a four-story building, and replace an aging strip mall, two office buildings and a handful of single family homes.

On the southeast corner, the council denied a proposal from Opus Corp. and Chase Bank for a three-story building with retail on the ground floor and condos above, on vacant land east of the bank building, widely recognized for its unusual design. But failure to win an agreement to preserve the bank building for longer than 10 years led to the denial.

On the northwest corner, M3 Companies withdrew its proposal for the CamelSquare site after the council rejected a request for more time that M3 said it needed to redesign the project in conformance with the Phoenix Planning Commission's recommendation a month ago that the buildings go no higher than 70 feet.

New proposals can be filed with the city after a year from the original filing. [Note: For first mention of this brewing issue, click here.]

Historic preservation discussed at recent Arizona Town Hall on land use

[Source: Arizona Town Hall] -- Arizona’s recent and projected population growth means that change is inevitable. This inevitable change will have a profound impact upon the quality of life and the sustainability of the environment of our state unless addressed by prudent, informed, innovative and coordinated land-use planning. Arizonans must look beyond the practices of the past and embrace a series of land use changes that:
  • Include enactment of comprehensive State Land Department reform;
  • Promote effective intergovernmental collaboration and cooperation;
  • Balance the human, natural, and cultural resources;
  • Embrace conservation opportunities; and
  • Recognize the responsibility of all citizens to work towards a prosperous, livable, sustainable, and economically responsible future.

The participants of the 91st Arizona Town Hall, drawn from across the state, met for three days of thoughtful discussion and deliberations, inspired by the majesty of the Grand Canyon as a backdrop. These citizens believe that the time has come to face the challenges of future growth by making hard land use choices for the 21st century. This Town Hall addressed population growth; the balance of responsibility for land use planning and regulation among local, regional, tribal, federal, and state governments; and the effectiveness of collaboration among tribal and non-tribal communities. Participants examined the interface of land-use planning with transportation, education, water, energy, and state trust land issues. They debated the best approaches to creating livable communities and considered the roles of financing and incentives in directing change.

The results of these discussions are included in this report (in PDF format). While not all Town Hall participants agree with each of the conclusions and recommendations, the report reflects the overall consensus achieved at the 91st Arizona Town Hall.

11/9 last day to nominate Phoenix Point of Pride

The following locations have been nominated during the current Phoenix Points of Pride election process. Since the nominations will be evaluated based on quality and merit and NOT the quantity of submittals, please do not submit your nomination form for new Point of Pride if you see it on the list below. Nominations will be accepted through Nov. 9, 2007. Click here to complete the easy, one page nomination form.
  • ASU - Downtown Campus
  • ASU - West Campus
  • Arizona 9/11 Memorial
  • Biltmore Fashion Park
  • Brophy Bridle Path
  • Brophy College Preparatory
  • Burton Barr Central Library
  • Canaan In The Desert
  • George Washington Carver Museum and Cultural Center
  • Cesar Chavez Park
  • Chase Bank Building and Grounds (44th St. & Camelback Rd.)
  • Chase Field
  • Dodge Theatre
  • Downtown Phoenix Public Market
  • Eastlake Park
  • La Cascada II Senior Affordable Housing Community
  • Lincoln Learning Center
  • MacAlpines Soda Fountain and Restaurant
  • Margaret Hance Park
  • Maryvale Baseball Park
  • Maryvale Community Center
  • Melrose on Seventh Street
  • Mercado del Paraiso at Ranch Markets
  • Metro Manor Townhomes
  • Monroe School
  • Murphy's Bridle Path
  • North Mountain Visitor Center
  • Pecos Community Center
  • Performing Arts Center at South Mountain Community College
  • Pete's Fish and Chips
  • Phoenix Children's Hospital
  • Phoenix Museum of History
  • The Phoenix Towers
  • Piestewa Peak Park
  • Pioneer Living History Museum
  • Royal Palms Hotel
  • St. Joseph's Hospital and Medical Center
  • Steele Indian School Park
  • Tradiciones Restaurant and Mercado
  • J. W. Walker Central Arizona Light & Power Building
  • Booker T. Washington School
  • Westward Ho

Wednesday, November 07, 2007

Changing times challenge Higley shops

[Source: Jenifer DeLemont, Tribune] -- Progress has taken its toll on two pillars of the Higley community. Two shop owners who have operated for years at Higley and Williams Field roads said development, street widening and changing clientele may soon force them to close their doors or relocate. “When people come in they really do seem to love the place,” said Vinny Barone (pictured), owner of San Tan Indian Arts at the heart of the historic Higley area. “It’s just hard to get people to come in anymore.” Barone said he may shut down at the end of the year and rent the space to a business that appeals more to the city dwellers who are taking over the south East Valley. Sylvia Babbitt, who owns Country Casa Furniture Gallery next door, said no one seems to notice the tiny strip mall anymore in a changing area that Gilbert annexed a few years ago. She said roadwork in the area might be the last straw that pushes her to relocate or close her retail business.

[Note: To read the full article, click here. Photo source: Thomas Boggan, Tribune.]

Monti’s owner scraps plan for towers

[Source: Garin Groff, Tribune] -- The owner of Monti’s La Casa Vieja has scrapped plans to build a 300-foot-tall tower directly above the historic adobe restaurant after a barrage of criticism from preservationists. Michael Monti still is planning for two towers to rise on his downtown Tempe property, but he has agreed to move one of them. Monti’s new plan comes weeks after the city’s Historic Preservation Commission objected to the idea of putting a 25-story building over the Valley’s oldest structure, built in 1871. Historic preservationists argued the building’s history would be overshadowed by a glass-and-steel tower. And the original plan likely would get the building kicked off a state and a national historic register, the state’s historic preservation officer has said.

While Monti argued he was preserving the interior, he and developer 3W Companies accommodated the historic commission’s request to move the new building. “It’s as important in the restaurant business, like politics, to have as high an approval as possible,” said Jason Rose, a spokesman for Monti. The new plan will likely get a good reception now, said Bob Gasser, chairman of Tempe’s historic commission. The group will hear the new proposal Thursday. “Even some of the strongest voices, I think, will be pleased with this,” Gasser said. If the group signs off on the plan, the towers face another source of opposition: The City of Phoenix. The buildings are about 80 feet too tall given their place in the flight path, Phoenix aviation director Danny Murphy told Tempe officials in a letter. The buildings could pose a risk to planes departing from Sky Harbor International Airport in the rare event that an airliner lost one engine during takeoff. To clear the building safely, Phoenix says the building shouldn’t exceed 220 feet.

[Note: To read the full article, click here. Photo source: Monti's.]

Friction between fair, Phoenix neighbors continues to rise

[Source: Sadie Jo Smokey, Arizona Republic] -- Three weeks out of the year a steady stream of trucks, SUVs and family sedans cruise up and down the streets of the Villa Verde Historic District in central Phoenix. Since the Arizona State Fair started Oct. 12, residents with orange traffic flags, flashlights and handmade signs have waved down drivers, selling spots on their fading Bermuda lawns for $3 to $20 each. "I need cheap parking," said Estee Hughes, of Phoenix, as she drove her silver Saturn onto Ed Franklin's lawn. "It's ridiculous. We drove around. Everyone's charging $15, $20." Hughes gave Franklin $7 and with her three daughters in tow, walked a few blocks to the entrance of the Arizona Exposition and State Fair park. The fairgrounds at 19th Avenue and McDowell Road, has 3,300 spaces and charges $12 per vehicle. That isn't enough on site parking for the tens of thousands of fairgoers. So, since the late 1920s, residents on four streets tucked between 19th and 20th avenues, have made lemonade out of lemons --crowds, car fumes, pedicabs and late-night noise - by selling parking on their lawns. But residents of the 110 homes in the neighborhood are at odds over parking during the three-week fair and have complained to the city.

[Note: To read the full article, click here. Photo source: Arizona Republic.]

Tuesday, November 06, 2007

Tempe's Monti's restaurant owner proposes new tower

[Source: Matt Culbertson, ASU Web Devil] -- One of Tempe's oldest buildings could soon get a facelift in the form of high-rise condominiums and retail establishments. Michael Monti, the owner of Monti's La Casa Vieja, a restaurant on Mill Avenue, said he will submit revised plans to the Tempe Historic Preservation Commission Thursday to build a hotel and condominium tower. It is important for the restaurant to make a dramatic statement for people entering Tempe since it is one of the first buildings visitors see when they arrive via Mill Avenue, Monti said. "We want people to have a dramatic awareness that they have entered into a unique downtown," he said. The Tempe Historic Preservation Office submitted a staff report last week to the commission with recommendations for how to redevelop Monti's but still keep the historic value of the building. Monti's, built as a home in 1871, is arguably the most significant historic resource in Tempe, according to the staff report.

[Note: To read the full article, click here. Photo source: Monti's.]

Monday, November 05, 2007

ACHP's 2008 section 106 course schedule

[Source: National Trust for Historic Preservation] -- The only Section 106 course taught by the federal agency responsible for administering the National Historic Preservation Act’s Section 106 review process, this two‑day course is designed for those who are new to Section 106 review or those who want a refresher on its basic operation. The course explains the requirements of Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act, which applies any time a federal, federally assisted, or federally approved activity might affect a property listed in or eligible for the National Register of Historic Places.

January 16-17 : Houston, TX - Hyatt Regency Downtown
March 12-13 : Providence, RI - Hotel Providence
April 8-9 : Santa Fe, NM - Hilton Santa Fe
May 14-15 : Washington, DC - The Old Post Office Building
June 17-18 : Pierre, SD - Ramkota Hotel & Conference Center
July 8-9 : San Diego, CA - Courtyard by Marriott Downtown
August 26-27 : Seattle, WA - Crowne Plaza Seattle
September 3-4 : Atlanta, GA - Westin Peachtree Plaza Hotel
October 20-21 : Tulsa, OK - In Conjunction with the National Trust for Historic Preservation Annual Meeting

New in 2008!!
Advanced Section 106 Seminar

This advanced class is designed for environmental and cultural resources personnel and focuses on the effective management of complex or controversial undertakings that require compliance with Section 106 of the National Historic
Preservation Act. Taught in a smaller, interactive setting, key topics discussed will include how to use consultation to resolve disputes, identifying creative ways to address conflicts between development plans and preservation values, and how to negotiate and prepare agreement documents.

April 8 : Salt Lake City, UT - Hotel Monaco
June 19 : San Francisco, CA - Serrano Hotel
August 20 : Washington, DC - Ronald Reagan Building and International Trade Center

For complete information as well as registration procedures click here. Questions? Email Cindy Bienvenue or call 202-606-8521.

Don't let Phoenix's Luhrs Tower be bulldozed

[Source: Arizona Republic Opinions, Margaret Smith] -- I read with a lot of interest in The Phoenix Republic about the building boom of the '20s and '30s. The purchase of the Luhrs Tower is a great concern to me. My great uncle Henry Trost is the architect of the Luhrs Tower. The building was built by the architect firm of Trost & Trost in 1929. The building was the first high rise in Phoenix standing 15 stories high. I did check to see if the building was on the list of historical buildings. It is not. The paperwork was filed several years ago but you have to have the owner of the building sign on the line. At the time the owner did not want to sign. I hope that the City Council also directs the city preservation group to make sure the building in not bulldozed down. Please keep the building as is so that my children can share their family history with future generations in Phoenix. [Photo source: camerafiend.]

Friday, November 02, 2007

City of Phoenix seeks consultants for National Register nomination

[Source: City of Phoenix]-- The City of Phoenix is seeking qualified consultants to prepare a nomination that will list 10 neighborhoods in Phoenix, Arizona, on the National Register of Historic Places (NRHP). The nomination is being funded by $125,000 in City of Phoenix Historic Preservation Bond funds. The anticipated start date is April 1, 2008. A draft version of the nomination will need to be submitted to the City Historic Preservation Office by March 31, 2009.

Scope of Work:

The consultant will be responsible for all tasks necessary to prepare the National Register nomination, including background research, field reviews, evaluation, photography, completion of all necessary forms, and periodic meetings with City and State Historic Preservation Office staff. The nomination will take the form of an amendment to an existing Multiple Property Submission (MPS) titled “Historic Residential Subdivisions and Architecture in Central Phoenix, 1912-1950.” To read the existing MPS, click here. In addition to updating the existing Multiple Property Documentation Form (MPDF), the consultant will be required to prepare National Register Registration Forms for each of the 10 new districts.

Section E of the existing Multiple Property Documentation Form includes three historic contexts:

Trends and Patterns of Residential Subdivision in Phoenix, 1912-1950; The Progression of Residential Architectural Styles and Building Technology in Phoenix, 1910-1950; and The Influence of Federal Programs on Neighborhood Development and Architectural Form in Phoenix, 1934-1950.

It is not anticipated that any new contexts will need to be created; however, each of the three existing contexts will need to be expanded significantly to incorporate the 10 additional districts (for example, some of the districts have periods of significance that end after 1950). The consultant will also need to update Section F of the MPDF to create new property types and registration requirements. Sections G (Geographical Data), H (Summary of Identification and Evaluation Methods) and I (Major Bibliographical References) may also need to be updated.

The 10 districts to be nominated to the National Register are as follows:

Campus Vista, 1939-1956, Osborn to Thomas Roads, 7th to 15th Avenues; East Evergreen, 1909-1929, McDowell Road to Interstate 10, 3rd to 7th Streets; Encanto Manor, 1945-1959, Thomas Road to Windsor Avenue, 7th to 15th Avenues; Encanto Vista, 1943-1953, Windsor Avenue to Encanto Boulevard, 7th to 8th Avenues; Garfield, 1883-1942, Roosevelt to Van Buren Streets, 7th to 16th Streets; Los Olivos, 1906-1935, Monte Vista Road between 3rd & 7th Streets; North Garfield, 1887-1942, Interstate 10 to Roosevelt Street, 7th to 16th Streets; Villa Verde, 1928-1940, Monte Vista to Granada Roads, 19th to 20th Avenues; Woodlea, 1928-1949, Glenrosa Avenue to Mackenzie Drive, 7th to 15th Avenues; Yaple Park, 1928-1940, Grand Canal to Turney Avenue, 3rd to 7th Avenues. All 10 of the proposed National Register districts are currently listed on the Phoenix Historic Property Register. Click here to view maps for each district. Additionally, staff reports were completed for each district at the time they were listed on the Phoenix Register. These reports should be used as a starting point for completion of the National Register Registration Forms and will be posted online prior to the pre-submittal conference (see below for more information). The Historic Preservation Office also has information files on all 10 districts that may be useful in preparing the nominations.

The Arizona State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) requires that State of Arizona Historic Property Inventory Forms be completed for all properties included in National Register historic districts, regardless of whether the properties are contributing or noncontributing to the district. These forms are typically 3 pages in length and are available online. If an inventory form already exists but is over 3 years old, a 1-page “update form” will need to be completed. The update forms must be affixed to the original survey form for the property.

The 10 proposed districts contain approximately 1,800 total properties. Approximately 200 of these properties lack inventory forms and will need to have new forms created. The remaining 1,600 properties have outdated inventory forms and will need update forms. Both the new forms and update forms require new photographs. Staff strongly recommends the use of digital photos for all Arizona Historic Property Inventory Forms and National Register Registration Forms. Please refer to the National Register Photo Policy Expansion for more information on requirements for digital photos used in conjunction with the National Register Registration Forms. The photos for the Arizona Historic Property Inventory Forms do not need to meet National Register standards and may be inserted electronically into the forms before they are printed. Please note that within the last year the City of Phoenix has taken digital photos of all properties in the Garfield and North Garfield Historic Districts; the consultant is encouraged to use these photos rather than taking new ones.

Please note that all survey forms should be logically arranged (either by survey site number or ascending address within street) and compiled in a binder for submission to the SHPO. Sketch maps for each district must be professional quality and provide information about contributor/ noncontributor status, street address, survey site number, and footprint of the house. Location of general district streetscape photographs also needs to be present on the map.

DELIVERABLES & DEADLINES
The end product will be the following:

Updated National Register MPDF (including expanded contexts, property types and registration requirements); National Register Registration Forms for 10 new districts, including attachments (USGS map, sketch map, black & white photos); and Arizona Historic Property Inventory Forms for all properties within the 10 new districts (approximately 200 complete forms and 1,600 update forms). The consultant will be required to submit two printed originals and two electronic copies (on recordable CDs, DVDs or similar electronic media) of each of the above items. One printed original and one electronic copy will be kept by the City of Phoenix and the second set will be submitted to the SHPO and National Park Service.

The deadlines for this project are as follows:

June 30, 2008: Completion of ½ of inventory forms
August 31, 2008: Completion of all inventory forms
October 31, 2008: Completion of draft MPDF and one historic district registration form
January 31, 2009: Completion of four additional historic district registration forms
March 31, 2009: Completion of all remaining historic district registration forms

In addition to the deadlines above, the consultant will attend monthly meetings with staff to report progress on the project.

PLEASE NOTE: The project will not be completed until the National Park Service approves the final document. The consultant will be required to make any corrections to the nomination requested by the SHPO, the Arizona Historic Sites Review Committee (HSRC) or the National Park Service prior to final approval. At least 10 percent of the overall budget should be allocated for these corrections. All necessary corrections should be completed within 90 days of SHPO request. The consultant will be required to attend the meeting(s) at which the HSRC reviews the nomination.

BUDGET

The total budget for this project will not exceed $125,000. This includes all items in the scope of work, any necessary corrections, and reimbursable expenses. Invoices may be submitted periodically throughout the project, as each deliverable item is completed. The project will be funded by City of Phoenix Historic Preservation Bond funds.

PRE-SUBMITTAL CONFERENCE

The City of Phoenix Historic Preservation Office will hold a pre-submittal conference on Tuesday, November 27, at 2:00 p.m. at the Ellis-Shackelford House, located at 1242 North Central Avenue, Phoenix, Arizona. All consultants interested in this project are encouraged to attend. At this meeting staff will discuss the scope of work, general contract issues and respond to questions from the attendees.

STATEMENT OF QUALIFICATIONS CRITERIA

Each Statement of Qualification (SOQ) will be evaluated according to the following criteria:

30% Understanding and approach to this project, including discussion of the important considerations of the project and how the team/consultant will address the project issues. Discuss your methods and successes in maintaining project budgets and schedules.

25% Experience and qualifications of the consultant in providing these services on similar projects. Provide explanation on how similar projects relate to this scope of work.

25% Experience and qualifications of the project team including sub-consultant experience and Minority/Woman-Owned Business Enterprise participation. If more than one consultant is involved, specify team members’ roles in the projects identified and include an organizational chart and resumes of key personnel expected to be assigned to the project.

10% Current/recent workload with the City of Phoenix. List projects awarded to your firm by the City during the last two years. For each project, provide the project description, award date, cost estimate and percent of the work currently completed.

5% Principal office locations and local office work role. Identify each of the staff member’s home office and the percent of the work to be performed at the local office.

5% Overall evaluation of the consultant’s or team’s capability to provide the required services on this project.

SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS

Firms interested in the above project should submit a Statement of Qualifications (SOQ) which includes a one-page cover letter plus a maximum of twelve pages to address the SOQ criteria (excluding resumes, but including the organization chart). Resumes for each key team member shall be limited to a maximum length of two pages and should be attached as an appendix at the end of the SOQ. Please provide an original plus five copies (total of six) of the Statement of Qualifications by 12:00 noon on Monday, December 17, 2007.

Firms interested in submitting on this project must be in compliance with the City of Phoenix Affirmative Action Ordinance. The firm’s Affirmative Action expiration date must be on each submittal cover. Questions should be directed to the Equal Opportunity Department at (602) 262-6790. Forms and additional information are available online.

Depending on the number of SOQs received, staff may choose to conduct interviews with the consultants. If interviews are deemed necessary, they will be held on Tuesday, January 22, 2008. Firms to be interviewed will be contacted no later than Friday, January 4, 2008. If you have any questions regarding the scope of this project, consultant selection process or contract issues, please contact Kevin Weight, Planner III, Historic Preservation Office at (602) 495-7610.

Petrified Forest and Taliesin West move toward recognition as world treasures

[Source: Eric Graf, Cronkite News Service] -- Petrified Forest National Park and Frank Lloyd Wright's Taliesin West have taken a first step toward being recognized among the world's most significant cultural and natural treasures. The National Park Service has recommended that the northern Arizona park and Wright-designed buildings in Arizona and other states be included in a tentative list for consideration to join the UNESCO World Heritage List. United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization already lists the Grand Canyon and 19 other U.S. sites among 851 treasures worldwide. Among the others: Yellowstone National Park, the Great Barrier Reef in Australia, the Taj Mahal in India and Stonehenge in the United Kingdom. Based on applications from around the country, the Park Service on Wednesday posted 35 sites on the Federal Register, providing 30 days for public comment. That begins a process that could take a decade. Brad Traver, acting superintendent at Petrified Forest National Park, said getting on the worldwide list would give the park the recognition it deserves. "We think this park has world-class resources," he said. "They are unique in the United States." The designation could also help boost interest in the Petrified Forest, said Bill Parker, a paleontologist at the park. "This would raise our visibility with international travelers," he said. "Also, it would raise our visibility to donors." Following the 30-day comment period, the Petrified Forest would be included on a new U.S. World Heritage Tentative List considered for formal nomination by the United States as a World Heritage Site.

[Note: To read the full article, click here. Photo source: National Parks Service.]

Meeting tonight in Oro Valley to discuss Steam Pump Ranch plans

[Source: Danielle Sottosanti, Daily Star] -- Three different plans for developing Steam Pump Ranch into a historic preserve with varying levels of commercial development will be discussed tonight in Oro Valley. The ranch, which Mayor Paul Loomis once called a cornerstone in Oro Valley history, consists of 15 acres off of North Oracle Road, south of Tangerine Road. Consultants Poster Frost Associates Inc. and Sage Landscape Architecture & Environmental Inc. recently presented plans for each scenario to a task force assembled to make a final report to the Oro Valley Historic Preservation Commission and Town Council in April. They will present the same plans at tonight's public meeting, the second of three public meetings scheduled. The third will be held Jan. 10. "The three alternatives will be presented to give residents of Oro Valley ideas about what Steam Pump Ranch could consist of," said Pamela Pelletier, town planner and project manager. "None of the designs are final, and the components of each plan can be incorporated into one ideal plan, but to do this we need public input on the proposals," she said. Each scenario for the historic site looks at the area's history from a different perspective.

[Note: To read the full article, click here. Photo source: Barbara Marriott.]

Thursday, November 01, 2007

Mesa looking for new historic preservation officer

Stephanie Bruning, Historic Preservation Officer for the City of Mesa, has moved to North Las Vegas to become a Senior Planner. The City is conducting a national search to replace Stephanie. If you or someone you know is qualified, consider putting your hat in the ring! Click here for a PDF of the job announcement.

Phoenix's Tovrea Castle construction progress

[Source: Barbara Stocklin] -- The Tovrea Castle Phase II restoration project was issued its notice to proceed in mid-November, and since that time cactus have been removed and relocated from around the castle building to make way for extensive excavation and structural reinforcement work needed for the basement tunnels. Work is schedule to continue for about a year, with a November 2008 completion date. [Photo source: City of Phoenix.]

Two book signings during Wickenburg home tour Saturday

[Source: Wickenburg Sun] -- As part of the festivities of the annual Wickenburg home tour during the weekend of Nov. 3-4, two celebrated authors will autograph their books for the public. Conrad Storad, well-known children’s author will be at the Community Center on Saturday, Nov. 3 from 11 a.m. to 2 p.m. He will be signing his books, which include “Don’t Call Me Pig,” “Life in the Slow Lane,” “Desert Night Shift,” and “Lizards for Lunch.” Betty Reid will sign her new book, “Navajo Women: Saanii” in the Desert Caballeros Western Museum lobby on Saturday, Nov. 3 from 11 a.m. to 2 p.m.

Storad is currently the director of the Office Research Publications at Arizona State University. He is the author of 24 science and nature books for children and young adults. Two years ago, as part of her program to promote reading, Governor Janet Napolitano selected Storad’s book “Don’t Call Me Pig! (A Javelina Story).” He has won many awards and honors for his educational and fun children’s books. Betty Reid is a native Navajo raised on the reservation living in Phoenix. She found herself routinely straddling the traditional and modern worlds, and experiencing conflicts in the generational gaps between the two. Her newest title, “Navajo Women: Saanii,” is a tribute to the generations of Navajo matriarchs.